The ruling by rhodes that public employee pensions could be reduced in chapter 9 bankruptcy was a landmark decision, says john pottow, a university of michigan law school professor who. Rhodes said the city met every test of insolvency, including failing to pay its debts and being. It is the largest municipal bankruptcy filing in u. Dec 04, 20 the companies still face potential claims on bonds issued by puerto rico and insolvent u. The petition was filed in the united states bankruptcy court for the eastern district of michigan, southern division, and was. Detroit to be a debtor in this chapter 9 case under 11 u. If youre having trouble paying bills, or youve suffered a setback like job loss, divorce, or illness, bankruptcy can help you get a fresh.
Notice of successor judge designation for the city of detroit bankruptcy case. Nov 07, 2014 the ruling, which will be issued in print later this month, puts an end to the largest municipal bankruptcy in u. The detroit free press explains the next steps here. Miller cohen, plc 7700 second avenue, suite 335 detroit, mi 48202 phone. Youll file your forms with the local bankruptcy court along with a filing fee or fee waiver and proof that youve taken the mandatory counseling course more below. The world socialist web site also spoke to robert, a retired detroit bus mechanic, who denounced the imposition of an emergency manager and the bankruptcy process as undemocratic. There were precedents for state intervention before detroits bankruptcy filing. Judge rhodes approves detroit bankruptcy plan with rhodes decision, the city is expected to cut about 74% of its unsecured debt, freeing up significant cash to reinvest in services. Detroit, the largest us city to file for federal bankruptcy, no longer has the resources to provide its residents with basic services, the judge ruled, saying it could seek to trim public pensions.
The ruling by the detroit bankruptcy judge created new law that is likely to be appealed, with no final decision for some time. Consequences of detroits bankruptcy for pensioners a. Detroits bankruptcy ruling and its relevance to sdcers. The judge, steven rhodes of united states bankruptcy court, agreed to the hearing requested by detroits emergency manager in response to a. Eastern district of michigan united states bankruptcy court. Detroit files for bankruptcy news of the nation, 20. Detroit falls into bankruptcy after decades of decline. Detroit files for bankruptcy news of the nation, 20 year. The circumstances that led to the detroit bankruptcy filing have. The detroit bankruptcy ruling 5 december 20 the detroit bankruptcy ruling handed down tuesday is a turning point in class relations in the united states. In ruling that detroit was eligible for chapter 9 and that pension debt could be impaired during the case, the court emphasized that it would not lightly or casually exercise the power under. Plan to exit bankruptcy is approved for detroit the new. Judge steven rhodes believes that a ruling on the bankruptcy issues will end sometime during the week of november 3 rd, with proceedings starting as early as october 27 th.
The companies still face potential claims on bonds issued by puerto rico and insolvent u. Dec 04, 20 a federal judge in michigan ruled on tuesday that detroit can cut public pensions as it enters bankruptcy. Going broke one city at a time pacific research institute. Detroit bankruptcy ruling good news for muni bonds, insurers. Bankruptcy is a federal process, but youll need to know some of michigans state laws and procedures, too. The group added, we are working with other detroit employees to form a unified coalition to address the financial concerns of detroit. Jul 18, 20 detroit has more than double the population of the northern california community of stockton, calif. Bankruptcy court judge overseeing detroits case will hold a hearing on wednesday on orrs request to extend chapter 9s automatic freeze on.
Jul 18, 20 the detroit free press explains the next steps here. The ruling by judge steven rhodes, who is overseeing the. City of detroit, michigan on thursday, july 18, 20 the city of detroit filed a petition seeking bankruptcy protection and the adjustment of debts under chapter 9 of the united states bankruptcy code. Introduction to the facts leading up to the bankruptcy filing. Fire fighters will continue to protect and serve during this difficult time, regardless of the economic challenges. Articles miller cohen, plc detroit, michigan attorneys.
Regardless of the detroit rulings immediate impact, sdcers has sufficient funds to pay its current and future retirees for decades to come, even if no additional plan sponsor contributions were received. Detroit has more than double the population of the northern california community of stockton, calif. Bankruptcy costs detroit retirees local news detroit. On july 19, 20, ingham county circuit court judge rosemarie aquilina ruled, using a typed statement with handwritten notes attached, that the bankruptcy filing by detroit violated the michigan constitution by impairing pension payments and ordered snyder to withdraw the filing. Dec 03, 20 detroit, the largest us city to file for federal bankruptcy, no longer has the resources to provide its residents with basic services, the judge ruled, saying it could seek to trim public pensions.
Dec 03, 20 detroit ruling reveals pensions not protected in bankruptcy. The city of detroit was handed a landmark ruling and a blessing to go forward as it exited in just over 16 months the nations largest municipal bankruptcy filing. There are essentially three costs to filing michigan bankruptcy cases with the help of a lawyer. Municipal finance after the detroit bankruptcy state bar of michigan. Sdcers detroits bankruptcy ruling and its relevance to. City asks detroit bankruptcy judge to stay lawsuits involving 36th district court attorneys for the city of detroit want a bankruptcy judge to put a hold on claims against 36th district court, which is funded by the city. The filing begins a 30 to 90day period that will determine whether the city is eligible for chapter 9 protection and define how many. Nov 10, 2014 federal judge approves detroit pension cuts. Judge approves detroit bankruptcy plan detroit free press. Detroit is also the largest city by population in the u.
Cuts to pensions of detroit retirees go into effect. Judge disallows plan by detroit to pay off banks the new. The ruling, which will be issued in print later this month, puts an end to the largest municipal bankruptcy in u. That ruling made detroit the largest city in american history to officially go bankrupt. The federal bankruptcy judge overseeing detroit s municipal bankruptcy case will announce on dec. The petition was filed in the united states bankruptcy court for the eastern district of michigan, southern division, and was assigned case number 53846. Detroit resurrected is a natural extension of that shoeleather reporting. Nov 21, 2014 the chapter 9 bankruptcy woes that have hit detroit are starting to come to a resolution.
Allen park office 6715 park avenue allen park, mi 48101. As lawmakers in springfield prepare to vote on a controversial pension reform plan, a federal bankruptcy court judge in detroit issued. Jul 18, 20 he city of detroit files for chapter 9 federal bankruptcy protection, making the automobile capital and onetime music powerhouse the countrys largestever municipal bankruptcy case. Detroit bankruptcy ruling nears the end own it detroit. Notice court closure february 2, 2015 fri, 11072014. Judge steven rhodes believes that a ruling on the bankruptcy issues will end sometime during the week of november 3rd, with proceedings starting as early as october 27th. The city of detroit filed for federal bankruptcy protection, making the automobile capital and onetime music powerhouse the countrys largestever municipal bankruptcy case. Chapter 9 city of detroit, michigan, case eastern district of michigan. Detroit files bankruptcy plan with federal court posted on march 3, 2014 by the law firm of kevin d. Hearing set for lawsuit disputing detroits bankruptcy filing. Closing arguments will be conducted on tuesday, october 28 th and wednesday, october 29 th. Jul 18, 20 on thursday, july 18, 20 the city of detroit filed a petition seeking bankruptcy protection and the adjustment of debts under chapter 9 of the united states bankruptcy code. Dec 05, 20 the detroit bankruptcy ruling 5 december 20 the detroit bankruptcy ruling handed down tuesday is a turning point in class relations in the united states.
Judge approves detroits exit from bankruptcy usa today. Detroit presents a study in the lessons of a large municipal bankruptcy. The chapter 9 bankruptcy woes that have hit detroit are starting to come to a resolution. The city of detroit, michigan, filed for chapter 9 bankruptcy on july 18, 20.
Jul 23, 20 the judge, steven rhodes of united states bankruptcy court, agreed to the hearing requested by detroits emergency manager in response to a michigan judges ruling that the citys chapter 9. The american federation of state, county and municipal employees, a union opposed to the bankruptcy filing, praised the judges ruling. Rhodes ruling will shape the citys trajectory and my work for months. Detroit retirees put on notice in bankruptcy ruling bloomberg. I have moved the article to the simpler detroit bankruptcy given there are not multiple bankruptcies. Welcome to the official website containing information for the city of detroit bankruptcy filing for the united states bankruptcy court for the eastern district of michigan. Bankruptcy court judge overseeing detroit s case will hold a hearing on wednesday on orrs request to extend chapter 9s automatic freeze on legal action to the lawsuits filed by the. Bomey was one of the journalists covering the bankruptcy for the detroit free press, not only the short hits of daytoday drama but also in longform features that contextualized the historic upheaval. In detroit, they are among 100,000 creditors owed money. Dec 03, 20 in ruling that detroit was eligible to reorganize under federal bankruptcy law, judge steven w.
Filing for bankruptcy in michigan has many benefits, including the protection of the automatic stay. Detroit resident katherine mingle wasnt surprised when the city filed for bankruptcy. Detroit files its bankruptcy plan with federal court. However, before you file for bankruptcy in michigan, you should discuss your financial situation with a michigan bankruptcy attorney, or the michigan bankruptcy court to determine if other options may be better for you according to your situation. Detroit retirees put on notice in bankruptcy ruling. Detroit usa was considered to be a city that epitomised the american dream of industrial. The detroit bankruptcy ruling world socialist web site. This article is brought to you for free and open access by flash. Bankruptcy code governs municipal government bankruptcy filings, but because of the. These are things that are only starting to become more definite with todays ruling from. Jul 24, 20 detroit s two pension funds, unions, and other creditors tried to argue that the citys bankruptcy case should not have been filed because the state cannot authorize a bankruptcy filing since it. The federal bankruptcy judge overseeing detroits municipal bankruptcy case will announce on dec.
Snyder has appealed the motion, and aquilina indicated she was sending a copy of her ruling to president obama. Apr 24, 2016 children play in the sand at campus martius park in downtown detroit, michigan, u. Detroit came up with a variety of creative fiscal solutions meant to benefit various subsets of its creditors, and, at least for now, it appears to have obtained the bankruptcy courts blessing. In response to the coronavirus outbreak, most bankruptcy courts remain operational. Introduction on july 18, 20, detroit filed for chapter 9 bankruptcy, becoming the largest municipality to file for bankruptcy in united states history. The historic ruling puts an end to the largest municipal bankruptcy in u. Bankruptcy judge steven rhodes detroit bankruptcy ruling, i got rerouted by the massive police raid on the martin luther king housing project, part of a citywide crackdown on hot spots for detroit s imposing crime. The inside story of detroits historic bankruptcy case detroit free press staff writers published 12. City of detroit bankruptcy filing eastern district of. Detroits two pension funds, unions, and other creditors tried to argue that the citys bankruptcy case should not have been filed because the state. Fitch published a research note on the bankruptcy ruling and concluded that detroits ruling would not lead to a spate of local. Court tosses challenges to detroits bankruptcy cnbc. Fitch ratings managing director amy laskey talked to fox business about how detroit is a unique story in muniland.
The milestone ruling could affect the retirement of millions of current and former municipal workers. In a document filed wednesday, lawyers argued claims against parties. I have also created the redirect bankruptcy of detroit. The milestone ruling could affect the retirement of millions of current and former. After municipal bankruptcy the pew charitable trusts. In ruling that detroit was eligible to reorganize under federal bankruptcy law, judge steven w. Bankruptcy judge steven rhodes detroit bankruptcy ruling, i got rerouted by the massive police raid on the martin luther king housing project, part of a citywide crackdown on hot spots for detroits imposing crime. Children play in the sand at campus martius park in downtown detroit, michigan, u. As lawmakers in springfield prepare to vote on a controversial pension reform plan, a federal bankruptcy court judge in. To free up the money, services have been cut, libraries and community centers. A federal judge in michigan ruled on tuesday that detroit can cut public pensions as it enters bankruptcy.
422 1308 105 1537 558 436 1381 776 1232 1655 245 157 913 886 661 1659 651 605 616 469 1392 68 1268 1477 1079 401 865 1329 523 1108 1558 1052 113 1459 551 1341 760 715 582